Criminal by Fiona Apple song meaning, lyric interpretation, video and chart position. Born Fiona Apple Maggart to Diane McAfee and Brian Maggart of New York in , she is vegetarian, and her albums include 's Tidal (featuring Shadowboxer, Sleep to Dream and Criminal), 's When the Pawn. Top definition. Fiona Apple's song “Criminal,” from her premiere album Tidal, that viewing a text as having a single meaning is an “interpretive fallacy. Time after time, pop stars push the boundaries of sexuality to sell music. Back in , crooner Fiona Apple got in hot water with her "Criminal". Fiona Apple · Tidal; Criminal Lyrics "Criminal" as written by Tarik L. Collins, Ahmir K. Thompson, Khari Abdul Mateen, Karl B. Criminal song meanings. Criminal meaning. Find out more about the meaning of Criminal by Fiona Apple. Dig into the lyrics, the cultural context of the song, and hear what the artist has. We look back on the controversy surrounding the video for Fiona Apple's biggest hit, "Criminal.". "Criminal" is a song by American recording artist Fiona Apple. It was released in September as the third single from the album Tidal (), and is Apple's. I first heard Fiona Apple in a dressing room at the GAP. It still dumbfounds me that an year-old girl wrote “Criminal,” a song about has taken on a new meaning with the pressures and emotional landmines of adulthood.